Help please

bluefield

New Member
I'm totally new to the world of civilian drones and I want to purchase one asap to help me with a major project I have. Here are the specs for what I need, and I would appreciate any assistance in helping me find the right/best drone to buy.

- I need to photograph (aerial, still photos definitely and would like movie as well) and map (see below) a 3,000 acre ranch in Florida.
- I know very little about civilian drones except for what a neighbor has told me and shown me about his DJI.
- I have flown some remote control aircraft - but I'm leaning toward a vertical take-off/helicopter-like drone because I hear they are easier to fly. True?
- Air or flight time per battery is probably important as I need it to cover a lot of ground, unless just getting more batteries is my best option.
- The quality of the photos (and movies if available) is important. I don't want to have fuzzy, low dpi pictures, since I have to do some photo-interpretation with them, and I would like to be able to print them in at least 8x10 and have the features discernible.
- The mapping I need is to be able to identify and note the drone's GPS location when certain things come into view or when it is over a certain feature. Plus, I need to be able to then coordinate/verify/ground-thruth that location with a GPS coordinate (paper and computer) map I have.
- I only have Mac/Apple products, and I need it to be able to be used with a MacBook Pro (2.3 GHz intel core i7) running OSX version 10.9.4 or newer; I also would like it to be used with an iPhone if possible (but the computer is more important).
- I'm not sure what other questions to ask, nor am I sure what other features or accessories I'll need, because I'm new to this.
- Since this is an important business/professional use I don't really want a "starter" drone.

And perhaps most critical of all...
- If you think that drones are past the "experimental stage", my budget is probably $3,000-4,000, but if this is a case of wait a year and they'll get light years better, maybe I'm better off paying less ($1,000) and getting an upgrade in a year or so? But - if the drones out now are good/reliable/worth the price - I would like to get a really good one.
- My need is now for something that can do what I need it to do, so I'm not opposed to paying the extra $.

In advance, thanks for the assistance.
 

Ronan

Member
Why not hire someone? A lot cheaper... $3000-$4000 isn't much of a budget for proper field mapping equipment.

Heck a high quality CIR camera is a few thousand already...

Maybe someone knows a cheap solution, but i'm doing field mapping with CIR/Multispectral camera's and my basic setup is a few times your budget.

Buying a phantom V+ and sticking a waypoint on it might do some basic field mapping but it's far from anything 'professional'. It would cost you around $2000.

Also i would go with a fix wing r/c aircraft. They are cheaper and fly longer distances (they stay up longer). That way is a lot cheaper than a multirotor.
 

bluefield

New Member
Thanks Ronan, I really appreciate you taking the time.

Have had to rule out hiring someone because the skill set and equipment for drone (specifically) photog + GPS mapping are not available in our region; would have to hire a traditional aerial photographer and a ground-based GPS mapper and bids for both came in at around $8,500.

Judging from your answer I might not be stating my needs/specs correctly. First, I need a drone with a good quality, regular camera, and not anything like what the military/full-time professionals use; I've seen drones like a Phantom with a 1080 dpi camera for around $1,500. My question here is: is the camera that comes on that unit just not very good? I don't need to ID eye color from 500', but it would be nice if I could ID an animal as a deer from 500'.

Second, it might be that my mapping specs are misleading as well: At the minimum-need end I need to be able to fly the drone over a small feature - say a 1 acre pond - and be able to see (on the screen) the GPS coordinates for it so I can either write it down or hit a button and save the image of the pond with the GPS coordinates. At the maximum-need end I'd like to be able to fly the drone along a flight path - say following a treeline - and have the path delineated on the screen or later printed; basically like with a standard head-held GPS, where you walk a path/trail and your route is drawn out. I probably don't know what other mapping features are also available, so I'm not sure what else I need.

I would love for the camera to have IR capabilities and/or night vision - and I've seen 1080 dpi hand-held IR cameras for like $300-400 - but if this is what blows the budget than I can do without it.

Regarding fixed-wing versus multi-rotor vertical take-off/land: a lot of my landscape is heavily mixed in terms of quite a bit of 150'+ trees in otherwise open prairies, so I just assumed that I'd need a vertical if I wanted to maneuver around and through these areas while photographing below 150'+. I worry about the learning curve (for me) for flying a fixed wing in these conditions (while multi-tasking); overall, isn't a vertical significantly easier to fly?

Again, thanks for your feedback - it is really helpful.
 

FlyGirl

Member
I worry about the learning curve (for me) for flying a fixed wing in these conditions (while multi-tasking); overall, isn't a vertical significantly easier to fly?

I can't really comment on most of your thoughts although I agree with Ronan that it would be cheaper and far faster to hire someone to do the work. There is a learning curve even if the multirotors look easy to fly (we love to show everyone how it hovers hands off). I fly both fixed and rotor and for both it takes some time to become proficient enough to know which way to move the sticks instinctively. If you have to think about it you're more than likely flying behind the curve and that's not a good thing. One other thing I want to bring up is that if you are flying, you really shouldn't be multitasking. It's the same as driving a car where it is also not a good thing. Most of us fly with spotters who can multitask somewhat which is far far safer... Just my 2 cents :)
 

Ronan

Member
Thanks Ronan, I really appreciate you taking the time.

Have had to rule out hiring someone because the skill set and equipment for drone (specifically) photog + GPS mapping are not available in our region; would have to hire a traditional aerial photographer and a ground-based GPS mapper and bids for both came in at around $8,500.

Judging from your answer I might not be stating my needs/specs correctly. First, I need a drone with a good quality, regular camera, and not anything like what the military/full-time professionals use; I've seen drones like a Phantom with a 1080 dpi camera for around $1,500. My question here is: is the camera that comes on that unit just not very good? I don't need to ID eye color from 500', but it would be nice if I could ID an animal as a deer from 500'.

Second, it might be that my mapping specs are misleading as well: At the minimum-need end I need to be able to fly the drone over a small feature - say a 1 acre pond - and be able to see (on the screen) the GPS coordinates for it so I can either write it down or hit a button and save the image of the pond with the GPS coordinates. At the maximum-need end I'd like to be able to fly the drone along a flight path - say following a treeline - and have the path delineated on the screen or later printed; basically like with a standard head-held GPS, where you walk a path/trail and your route is drawn out. I probably don't know what other mapping features are also available, so I'm not sure what else I need.

I would love for the camera to have IR capabilities and/or night vision - and I've seen 1080 dpi hand-held IR cameras for like $300-400 - but if this is what blows the budget than I can do without it.

Regarding fixed-wing versus multi-rotor vertical take-off/land: a lot of my landscape is heavily mixed in terms of quite a bit of 150'+ trees in otherwise open prairies, so I just assumed that I'd need a vertical if I wanted to maneuver around and through these areas while photographing below 150'+. I worry about the learning curve (for me) for flying a fixed wing in these conditions (while multi-tasking); overall, isn't a vertical significantly easier to fly?

Again, thanks for your feedback - it is really helpful.

I'm too far from Florida, but i thought we had some professional members in that area...

Those $300-$400 'ir' camera's are a joke, they barely work at a few feet distance, so imagine when you are 50-100 feet in the air. My thermal camera also has a IR sensor and it came out to almost 10 grande, used. That one will let you fly in the air and be able to see what's what on the ground, and even at that price... you still squint sometimes to make out shapes!

The cheapest system i can think about is a Phantom Vision+, add datalink waypoint, and go from that. It's FAR from the best, but it gives basic autonmous controls and GPS information. You are still looking at around $2k. You will need a laptop or a ipad to use the groundstation of the datalink system.

Vertical is very hard to fly, i always found airplanes to be easy, since they naturally tend to 'glide'. Helicopters and multirotors don't have that feature, it's very different.

I would honestly look around your state and nearby states for someone with the equipment to do this. Also $8,500 to have a helicopter do 3,000 acres is pretty cheap! Locally here they charge almost $2000 per hour, and require minimum 24 hours before processing the information. I do it for a lot less and all the information is ready by the end of the same work day, right on site.
 

Top